# Whether a meeting happened depends on which source saw it

"Took place" is an evidence rule over sources rather than a stored field.

By Ki Moon · 2026-10-12 · finding · current
Canonical: https://kihmoon.com/bench-notes/p/meeting-happened-is-evidence/

**Symptom:** Meeting counts include email threads that mention a date, past invites still marked scheduled, and transcript-born meetings with no state at all.

Most systems store a meeting state and trust it. Each source sets that state its own way, and none of them sees the whole meeting.

- Email chatter about a call becomes a dated "meeting".
- Calendar invites stay "scheduled" after the call happened.
- Meetings created from a transcript carry no state at all.

So "took place" is a rule over evidence. A meeting happened if a recording shows an external participant speaking. One that started and was neither cancelled nor inferred counts as presumed held, labelled that way and ranked below a recording. Recording outranks calendar, and calendar outranks email.

A stored state field can miss a large share of the meetings that a recording or a started calendar entry shows were held.

In a synthetic test set where 136 meetings were held, the stored state field marked 52 of them held, plus 30 that were not; the evidence rule caught all 136 and also counted 5 presumed meetings that were not held. The set shows the mechanism, not how common it is.

## Check your setup (read-only)

Take the rep with the most meetings last month, and that rep's last 20 past meetings. Count the meetings your stored "happened" field marks as held. Count the meetings with a recording of an external participant speaking, or a calendar entry that started and wasn't cancelled. A difference of more than 2 of 20 means the stored field is not the answer.

**Passes if:** The evidence count covers meetings with a recording of an external participant speaking or an uncancelled calendar entry. For the sampled rep's last 20 past meetings, the stored held count is within 2 of the evidence count.

**Access needed:** crm-read, call-data

## If it fails (changes to make later, not part of the check)

1. Count a meeting as held when a recording shows an external participant speaking. Count a meeting as presumed held when it started and was neither cancelled nor inferred from email. Rank presumed held below a recording.
2. Rank recording above calendar and calendar above email when sources disagree.
3. Give transcript-born meetings a held state from the recording itself when it shows an external participant speaking.
4. Compare your stored state against the evidence rule for one rep before trusting either.

**Applies if:** You back-fill meetings as CRM activity, or report meeting counts per rep, from more than one source: calendar, recorder or email.

**Skip if:** Every meeting you count comes from one recorder that only creates a record when a call is recorded.

Tags: meetings, data quality, measurement
